They are such an irresistible treat that will keep you cool on a hot summer day. Bring them to your next cookout, pool party, birthday party, and more! You’ll love how the cookie layer stays soft even when frozen, so you can eat this directly out of the freezer without worrying that the exterior is too hard or the ice cream squishing out of the sides. They make for the perfect individual snack you can fill your freezer with for whenever the craving hits. Trust me, they’re way better than store-bought. If you want another frozen dessert recipe, then try my ice cream cake, fried ice cream, or baked Alaska recipe.
What You Need to Make This Recipe
Ice cream — I’m using vanilla ice cream, but feel free to use your favorite ice cream flavor. Flour — you don’t need anything fancy to make this homemade ice cream sandwiches recipe. All you need is all-purpose flour! Cocoa — you can use natural unsweetened cocoa powder or Dutch process cocoa powder. Baking powder — for best results make sure the baking powder is fresh and not expired. This will keep the cookie layer from being too dense. Butter — as different butter brands use different amounts of salt in their salted butter, I recommend using unsalted butter. Be sure to bring the butter to room temperature. It must be soft enough so your finger leaves a dent when pressing it. Vanilla extract — I recommend using real vanilla extract over artificial vanilla extract. You can also try making my homemade vanilla extract for a flavorful DIY version! Eggs — make sure you use two large eggs. This will keep the cookie layer from becoming dry and crumbly.
How to Make Ice Cream Sandwiches
- Line a 13×9-inch baking pan with parchment paper. Spread the softened ice cream into the pan in an even layer and freeze until solid.
- Whisk together the flour, cocoa, baking powder, and salt in a medium bowl.
- In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, beat the butter and sugar on medium speed until light and fluffy. Stop and scrape down the sides of the bowl as needed.
- Beat in the eggs, one at a time, until evenly incorporated. Beat in the vanilla.
- Add the flour mixture and beat on low speed until fully combined. Spread the batter into a buttered 18×13-inch baking sheet lined with parchment paper. Heat oven and bake for 10 to 12 minutes.
- Let the cookie layer cool slightly in the pan. Run a small offset spatula around the edges of the cookie. Transfer the cookie with the parchment paper to a wire rack to cool completely. Transfer the cookie onto a cutting board and remove the parchment paper. Cut the cookie widthwise in half, creating two 9×13-inch slabs.
- Sandwich the scoop of ice cream between the cookie slabs, trimming the sides as needed to fit evenly. Wrap in plastic wrap and freeze until firm, 4 hours or up to overnight.
- Cut into 12 sandwiches using a warm serrated knife when ready to serve.
Pro Tips for Making This Recipe
I highly recommend using a warmed serrated knife to saw through the top cookie gently. The serrated blade helps cut through the cookie layer without causing them to crumble and prevents the ice cream from being pushed out. The longer you can let the assembled sandwiches freeze, the easier it is to cut. You can customize the ice cream filled sandwiches by pressing sprinkles, chocolate chips, or sanding sugar, crushed Oreo cookies, peanut butter, or nuts onto the edges. When preparing the ice cream layer to freeze, be mindful of how long it takes to soften your ice cream. You want the ice cream to be soft, not melted. More expensive ice cream will take less time to soften, and the temperature of your kitchen also plays a role. Set an alarm if you need to remember the ice cream on the counter, as refreezing melted ice cream will give it an undesirable grainy, dense texture. I suggest using store-bought ice cream as homemade no-churn ice cream tends to be softer and won’t hold up as well between the cookie layers. Also, most people do not have an ice cream maker. Don’t rush cooling the cookie layer. You want the cookie layer to be fully cooled, as the slab of ice cream will melt if the layers are still warm.
If you’ve tried this Homemade Ice Cream Sandwich recipe, then don’t forget to rate the recipe and let me know how you got on in the comments below, I love hearing from you!
